Sunday, July 19, 2026

130. The Writing/Talking Cure

Jack Nicholson in The Shining (1980)

How might Darlene's advice about "how to get through horror movies" ("narrate the scary parts") be more broadly relevant life advice?

To what extent is it true "that if you say it in your words, it's less scary somehow"? 

To what extent does writing something down help with emotional challenges--things that are sad, depressing, infuriating, frustrating, etc? Do the same advantages apply to talking? Praying?

Is there mere act of expression useful in itself? How important is to to have a reader or listener?

131. The heart wants


The phrase "The heart wants what the heart wants," which the author references on page 131, is sometimes used to justify, explain, or rationalize a decision that may seem irrational or unkind, as when people try to explain to each other why they are breaking up, why they have fallen out of love with one person or fallen in love with another.

To what extent are we, in fact, subject to the whims of our hearts? Is falling in and out love something that we have no control over?

If that is the case, what is the purpose of a marriage vow?

Earlier, the narrator reported that "a small part of me wants to fight. Fight for us. . . . For the kids, for the family. For the picture Noah and Lily had in their heads of us, the crayon renderings of which were hung up all over the house. For the marriage, for the younge rversion of ourseles who stood up in front of a room of people we loved and earnestly made promises we thought we could keep. for the poeple we were when we met and for hte people we thought we could grow into together" (6). Ultimately, though, she does not choose to fight.

If Sam has fallen out of love with the narrator and fallen in love with Maggie, what argument can be made against his decision to get a divorce?

Consider the narrator's earlier comments about how Sam's "earnest search for bliss and self seemed flighty" (38). Is the narrator suggesting that seeking happiness and self-realization should not always be someone's goal?

141. Irreversible

"Seat #12" (2016) by Jenny Brockman
with research group Irreversible Moment, Ernst Schering Foundation
Photo by Sebastian Mayer

Consider the author's comment about Lily that” “I see in my daughter the understanding that a single careless action can lead to a stain or an irreversible tear” (142)?

In light of this comment, why do you think the author puts the story of Noah’s accident in her story (132-135)?

Was the story about Noah's accident a story about about an irreversible tear?

145. Owned

"The Wedding" (1791-92) by Francisco Goya

When Noah asks his mother "Do I own myself? Do you?", she responds "Absolutely. And don't you forget it."(145)

The image that comes to her mind is the time when she walked herself down the aisle at her wedding. She was not "given away" by her parents or anyone else.

Do you agree with those who believe "giving away" the bride at a wedding is an unfortunate remnant of a time when daughters were considered property, even if that original significance is now long gone?

Is there any more helpful way in which someone might say that they do not "own" themselves, in the sense, for example, that they owe a debt to their community, the people who raised them, God or a higher power?

150. A giant ball of soul string mates

"The Tree of Life" (1909) by Gustav Klimt

The narrator tells her children that people have many soulmates, that they come in the forms of husband and wives as well as best friends and dogs, and that each of them have a quest to complete

What is the value in believing in the traditional view of soulmates?

What is the value in the narrator's view of soulmates?

Is her vision undermined by the image of the world as "a giant ball of tangled string. Lines getting crossed. People all knotted up with the wrong people" (151)? Does that image suggest that she and Sam were the wrong people for each other?

Is

151. Wealth Gap

Keira Knightley in Pride and Prejudice (2005)

The narrator describes her children in terms of the social class differences between her and Sam: "My kids are each half silver spoon and half service industry. Half homemade hands and half paying full price. Half clawed their way out of a rural province in China and half houses in several states" (151).

Do you think it is fair to say that the differences between people who grew up with greater wealth and those who grew up with less wealth is much more than money?

How likely is it that they have have profoundly different attitudes, expectations, and worldviews and sense of their place in society?

Do you know any people who have relationships that bridge wide social class divides?

161. Begin/End

"The Sower" (ca. 1865) by Jean-Francois Millet

Do you agree with the narrator that some people are “beginners” while others are “enders” (161)?

If so, what do these differences say about people and why do you think they have preferences for one or the other; if not, what is false about this assessment?

Which one of these do you identify with?

"The Gleaners" (1857) by Jean-Francois Millet