The phrase "The heart wants what the heart wants," which the author references on page 131, is sometimes used to justify, explain, or rationalize a decision that may seem irrational or unkind, as when people try to explain to each other why they are breaking up, why they have fallen out of love with one person or fallen in love with another.
To what extent are we, in fact, subject to the whims of our hearts? Is falling in and out love something that we have no control over?
If that is the case, what is the purpose of a marriage vow?
Earlier, the narrator reported that "a small part of me wants to fight. Fight for us. . . . For the kids, for the family. For the picture Noah and Lily had in their heads of us, the crayon renderings of which were hung up all over the house. For the marriage, for the younge rversion of ourseles who stood up in front of a room of people we loved and earnestly made promises we thought we could keep. for the poeple we were when we met and for hte people we thought we could grow into together" (6). Ultimately, though, she does not choose to fight.
If Sam has fallen out of love with the narrator and fallen in love with Maggie, what argument can be made against his decision to get a divorce?
Consider the narrator's earlier comments about how Sam's "earnest search for bliss and self seemed flighty" (38). Is the narrator suggesting that seeking happiness and self-realization should not always be someone's goal?