![]() |
| "Seat #12" (2016) by Jenny Brockman with research group Irreversible Moment, Ernst Schering Foundation Photo by Sebastian Mayer |
In light of this comment, why do you think the author puts the story of Noah’s accident in her story (132-135)?
Was the story about Noah's accident a story about about an irreversible tear?

I wouldn’t say that Noah’s accident is a story of an irreversible tear, rather it’s the first instance of this tear showing itself. This tear being the new distance between the narrator and her children. Although she has them the majority of the time she will no longer be there for all of the major events in their lives such as a traumatic injury.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your idea that Noah’s accident was not the irreversible tear but instead the first intend or sign of it. It was the first time that the narrator was enraged at Sam and did not seek with touch. This was the first time she saw him as immature or careless. We see this new look on Sam that she now has as we keep reading a few pages on too. It was also the first time something happened to her children when she was not around. That also had a role to play in this new tear.
DeleteI agree with both of these perspectives. We definitely see her attitude toward Sam shift in this moment. To add to that, she experiences a new emotion, anger. She wonders if Maggie was there. She is angry at Sam about their son getting hurt but I think she was also angry at Maggie because, after all, she is the reason the narrator wasn't there when the accident happened. Noah's injury isn't the tear, it's the new family dynamic and the rift in relationship with her children. Maggie (the lover, not the tumor) is the ultimate reason for the irreversible tear in their lives.
DeleteI think we have all had moments with irreversible events, like chipping a tooth or breaking a bone. A scar that will fade but never go away. Lily's care for the dresses draws attention and makes us more aware of the things that change as we get older. We can be as careful as we want, but nothing lasts forever. I think that the author includes Noah's injury to show that he continues to exist despite not being with the narrator. It shows that as we grow up, we have experiences of our own.
ReplyDelete