Sunday, July 19, 2026

7. Right Behind You

On page 7, the narrator makes the first of several references to a famous work by the renowned philosopher, Plato, namely, his “Allegory of the Cave.”

Are you familiar with Plato’s allegory? If not, check out the TED Ed Youtube video above.

Or click here to learn more.

The narrator asserts (in agreement with Plato) that the allegory shows that humans have a stubborn tendency to resist seeing “what’s lurking right behind us” (7).

What kind of things do you think people stubbornly avoid looking at? And why do they avoid them?

12. On Sale Now: Another Life

Still from "Pinocchio" (1940; dir. by Sharpsteen and Luske)

The narrator images a fairy tale life for her husband, the headhunter (a.k.a corporate recruiter), in which he "would be a mysterious merchant, a stranger blowing through town on the wind. . . . He would arrive in a place and go door-to-door and sell mortals another life that could be theirs. His powers would hinge on the irresistibility of snow not trodden on--all the paths you've never walked down" (12).

Do you think it is significant--or ironic--that this fantasy profession of selling mortals "another life" might also be a descriptor of the work of a novelist (like Yee) who offers readers the opportunity to imagine themselves as different people (like the narrator)?

Is the sinister warning that "if you don't read the fine print, [the merchant]'ll make off with your children" in any way relevant to the dangers of reading? In what way, might reading create a rift between parents and their children?

22. Odd Couples

Jack Klugman and Tony Randall
stars of TV's "The Odd Couple"(1970-1975)

The main character says that she and her college roommate Darlene had "nothing in common" other than a "baseline of understanding born from our shared exclusion" as "non-white people" on their college campus. They "joked that it was kind of racist" that they were paired together.

And yet, in spite of their many differences (described in part on page 22), they became best friends, and Darlene greatly enriched the main character's college experience.

This question set has several parts. You are free to answer any of them that you consider thought-provoking.

1) To what extent is it a good idea for housing offices to consider race when matching students? Should housing surveys ask students their race? Should they ask if students are comfortable rooming with some who is of a different race or from a different country? Should housing surveys allow students to share photos of themselves with other potential roommates? Should they allow students to see the names of potential roommates?

2) How common is it and how wise is it for students to seek out roommates who look like them, either in terms of physical features or in terms of the way they present themselves to the world on social media? 

3) How important is it to the college experience for someone to learn how to share living spaces with someone whose tastes, hobbies, and interests are different than theirs are?

4) How might college residential life offices encourage students to approach the experience of difference and novelty outside the classroom as an opportunity for growth and not as an obstacle?

25. Stalker

"A Fox Stalking a Brace of Partridges" (ca. 1712-1753) by Jean-Baptiste Oudry (1686-1755)

After the main character finds out about Maggie, she decides to "stalk her on the internet immediately"  (25).

Is "stalking" a fair description of what she does?

To what extent is it advisable or healthy for her to do this?

How likely is it to help her understand what has happened and is happening to her marriage or to help her process is emotionally?

How likley is it that she will learn something meaningful about Maggie and her husband's relationship with her from whatever she can find out about her online?

38. New book, new self


The narrator reports that when she was a little girl, she used to love the "book of hair" at her mother's stylist's shop, which included "colorful, tactful samples, little loops of real hair that were organized by gradation . . . You could hold a curl of your new color in your hand, hold it up to your face, see how it changed in the light" (38). She goes on to report that she was "fascinated" by "all these selves you could put on" (38).

Some might say that reading stories--like this novel--or hearing them also provide ways to "put on" different selves, take them for a turn, see what it feels like to be someone different, to face different kinds of challenges, and to make different kinds of choices. While some think of reading as nothing more than mindless entertainment, critic Kenneth Burke once observed, fiction provides readers with "equipment for living."

Do you think it is concerning that fewer people read novels these days than they did in the past? That Americans read less than Europeans? That men read less than women? (Click here to read more about recent trends.)

Why do you think readership rates are declining? What role do schools play in this trend?

What is the next book you want to read? Can you recommend a book you've recently read?

46. Truth Pollution


The narrator poses a series of questions that are the kind she has come across in "stupid online quizzes" that deal with the general question of "what lies you're willing to tell," such as "will you be the type of parent who tells lies about Santa Claus? The tooth fairy? The birds and the bees and death?" (43).

Later, when she tells her son a lie about Santa Claus and the tooth fairy, she insists that she "wanted to put the least possible number of lies into the atmosphere of our home, like they were exhaust fumes that would be bad to breathe in, that could stunt growth" (46).

Do you think adults tend to hide too much of the truth from children or do they expose them too early to truths they are not yet ready to confront?

When is it ok to hide truths from a loved one if you know that their emotional reaction might be both negative and inappropriate?

How important do you think it is to tell stories without exaggeration?

53. Waiting Rooms

"Waiting Room for the Beyond" (1988) by John Register

What did you think of the main character’s assertion that her cancer diagnosis “made every room a waiting room” (53)?

Since the human condition is terminal (we all die in the end), isn't this always true?

Do you think looking at life as a waiting room is morbid and depressing?

What are the potential benefits of thinking about life this way? What measures might someone take to foreground these benefits in their life? 

Does this relate back to Plato’s allegory?