Sunday, July 19, 2026

102. I am the roles I play?

Natalie Portman in Black Swan (2010)

Throughout the novel, the narrator reflects on her identity. When she was her son's age, she decided she wanted to be a writer and "clung to that identity. I thought it fit me in the way few other identities died at the time. I chased this sense of identity through high school and to college . . . Eventually, the ream caved under the weight of more tangible realities" (27).

A few pages later, she remarks on the “truest self” (31), the “core” (35) self. On page 102, she reflects on how roles (mother, wife, friend, occupation etc.) can both reinforce and undercut identity.

(Side note: Did you know that the study of identity formation is an area of specialization in the academic disciplines of philosophy and psychology?)

What are your (look – identity is in that word!) thoughts on  the relationship between roles and personal identity?

Is there a core self that is completely independent of the roles you play? Do roles do little more than mask the core self? Or is your core identity shaped by the roles you play--at work, in the family, with your friends, in public?

108. Shall Remain Nameless

"Hefeng - Gentle Breeze" (2021) by Hung Liu

The narrator claims that “my real name lived and died in the mouth of my mother” (108), as it was a Chinese name that was "stripped away in kindergarten" by an American teacher who told her she had to pick "An American name" (108).

The narrator then remarks on how many people must “scrub [themselves] down to the bone for survival” (108).

Imagine that you moved to a different country as a child and people insisted that you abandon the name your parents had given you and respond to a name that reflected their culture because they didn't want to try to learn how to pronounce or spell your name.

What effect might that have on you? Would that help you feel like a part of the culture? Or would it remind you that your true self (like your true name) could never be fully accepted?

In your experience, how common is it for people to "Americanize" someone's name or the pronunciation of it? If someone agrees to such a change or even requests it, is that sufficient reason to accept the practice without pushing back?

Can mispronouncing someone's name be fairly characterized as a micro-aggression?

116. Lists and Letters

"Still Life with a Skull and a Writing Quill" (1628) by Pieter Claesz

What do you think of the recommendation by a fellow patient that the narrator write letters to her kids “just in case” (106) (a fellow patient who she says she no longer sees – for “good or bad” on 116)? 

Why do you think the narrator focuses on writing lists (like the one on page 106) and not letters (the kind of "sentimental"thing someone like Maggie might do [106])?

What does this say about the kind of person she is?

118. Woulda, Coulda, Shoulda

"In a Park" (c. 1874 ) by Berthe Morisot

What keeps the narrator from wanting to imagine a fantasy version of her life where she never made eye contact with Sam at the bar where they met (118)?

Is there a valuable life lesson in her reflections on why she don't like to play that game?

Or is it an example of trying to make peace with the negative (bitterness about an unhappy marriage) by associating it with some positive repercussions?

124. Gifts of Time

"Mother and Child" (ca. 1980-1990) by Lin Fengmian

The narrator says waiting with her mother to see the doctor when she had cancer reminded her of the times when she was "waiting in those hair salons as a kid, waiting for my mother to be restored to some livelier version of herself" (124).

What is the impact of the narrator's story of her mother’s cancer and the role she played for her as a caretaker?

How does this shape her narrative and the narrative generally?

127. The Stories We Tell


Just as the main character likens herself, Sam, and their relationship to celestial forces (the earth, the rain the sun), she also likens them to animal ones, namely, whimsically as Shark and Lion, in conjunction to bath towels they had for Noah and Lily. She asserts that these animals are “the wild things we used to be” (127), and in making this remark, the author brings us back to a reference made on line 4 of page 1, Maurice Sendak’s Where the Whild Things Are.

Why do you think special attention is drawn to this other source (Where the Wild Things Are)? What is special about the narrative it tells and what parallels exist to this one? (If you haven't read the 1963 picture book Where the Wild Things Are or haven't read it recently, check it out at the library, online or at a local bookstore. The audiobook is literally 5 minutes long.

Consider the narrator's choice to reference this book twice by the light of her observation on page 128 about what "the kind of stories you choose to tell say about you." What does this story tell us about the narrator? Or the author?

Consider the main character's decions to start telling her children Chinese folk tales (page 39 and later) and the way she sees these stories as tangled up with her identity? How are you as a reader analogous to the children in the story in the sense that you are hearing these narratives too?

Do you or your family have any favorite stories or anecdotes that you frequently retell? What might they tell listeners about the story-tellers? Similarly are there any books or movies that you frequently re-watch? What do they say about your values and worldview?

D

128. Nooses

"Old Man with Noose" (1923)
by Kathe Kollwitz
When Noah tells the narrator that he likes "'nice stories' before bed," the narrator describes such stories as "the kind with happily-ever-afters that end in a neat little bow like a noose around the imagination" (128). That's a particularly dark way of describing stories with happily-ever-afters.

Why might the narrator think that happily-ever-after stories strangle the imagination?

Consider how this observation might relate to Sam's strategy of jumbling up bedtime stories in a crazy way that the children find delightful?

Does the author herself have a penchant for metaphorical flights of fancy and jarring juxtapositions that interrupt traditional reader expectations of narrative flow as she jumps from one section to the next?

How is the author's narrative style different from or similar to the main character's way of reading the children bedtime stories?